Skip to main content

Which woodsy candle feels like your kind of morning?

Ask two people what the woods smell like in the morning and you might hear about two completely different things. One remembers the evergreen branch hanging over a lake. The other remembers opening a cabin door while it’s still dark, dressed and ready to go. Both would be reasonable descriptions of a woodsy candle. They would lead you to different jars at McKibbin House.

Choose Up North Morning if pine and balsam fir are what you came for, especially if you like a little citrus and warm wood alongside them. Choose The Hunt if fir needle, evergreen forest and earthy musk sound closer to the woods you remember. The Hunt also carries a faint gun-oil impression. That last detail can be the easiest way to decide between the two.

Up North Morning begins in Michigan

For Chuck McKibbin, “up north” means something specific. He talked about camping in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, about snow deep enough for snowmobiles and about lakes where the morning could be wonderfully quiet. There are plenty of places with pine trees. It’s the water and the space to sit a while that help explain why this particular stretch of woods stayed with him.

The candle gives pine and balsam fir a place up front in its description. Birch and citrus brighten the profile. There’s warmth in the amber, sandalwood and embers, with vetiver among the listed notes as well. If you’re reading that list online, try taking it in two parts. The pine and fir tell you where you are. The other notes help you decide whether you’d like to stay.

Citrus is an especially useful clue. Someone who likes green scents with a bright edge has a reason to choose this candle over The Hunt. Someone looking for a candle that smells only of pine needles should read the rest of the profile carefully. The ember and sandalwood notes are part of what gives this interpretation of a Michigan morning its own character.

The Hunt starts with getting ready

When Chuck talked about hunting, he went straight to the preparation. There’s gear to organize. There’s a rifle to clean. Somewhere there’s a set of rattling horns that needs to turn up before anybody leaves. If you’ve ever laid your things out the night before an early start, you can probably understand the anticipation even if you’ve never hunted.

Fir needle and evergreen forest supply the green part of this profile. Earthy musk takes it in a different direction from the citrus in Up North Morning. Then comes the faint impression of gun oil. On paper it’s the least likely thing on the list. In the context of getting ready for a morning in the woods, it makes sense. It connects the outdoor setting to something someone actually does there.

Read that detail at the scale the description gives it: faint. The main choice here is whether you enjoy evergreen and earthy musk together. If you do, the unusual workshop-like detail may be exactly what makes the scent interesting. If you’d rather stay with trees, citrus and wood, Up North Morning gives you that choice without having to talk yourself into anything.

Three questions that narrow it down

First, which part of an evergreen scent do you usually go back for? If you love the smell of pine and balsam together, follow those words to Up North Morning. If what you remember is the earthy smell around the trees as much as the needles themselves, take another look at The Hunt. Both descriptions include evergreens, so that word by itself won’t get you very far.

Second, how do you feel about embers? Up North Morning has that note tucked into a wider woodland profile. If what you really want is the smell of sitting beside a fire with a toasted marshmallow, there’s another candle better suited to that particular memory. The Journal’s guide to smoky candles compares the campfire, desert and charcoal scents in the collection.

Third, what does the person you’re buying for actually enjoy about a trip outdoors? One person in the family is out before dawn, checking pockets and making sure everyone has what they need. Someone else has claimed a spot by the lake and would happily spend the first hour there. Either person might love the outdoors. Their answer tells you much more than a general label like “outdoorsman.”

A woodsy scent you can give in December and use in June

For a winter gift, it’s easy to reach for anything that mentions pine. A better clue is whether that person talks about the tree at Christmas, a particular summer campsite, or the first morning of hunting season. If they keep going back to that campsite, tell them you picked Up North Morning because of the lake. If they’re already sorting gear for next year, tuck that thought into a note with The Hunt.

You can compare both in the ten-scent collection. Read the first line of each profile and then look at the label. One shows a fire beside a mountain lake. The other looks out from the shelter of a cabin. Which morning would you like to wake up to?